Friday, December 14, 2012

Planning in Wales - One Party State Style

Just read reported comments to the BBC from the Welsh Gov't that has left me incandescent with anger. Only in what is effectively a one-party-state would such comments be made in the name of a government. Lets start with a bit of background.

In 2005, the then Welsh Gov't published 'guidance' for planning authorities about how to deal with renewable energy applications. This directed wind farm developers to 7 areas of Wales where permission for their obscenities could be granted. 3 of these areas were in mid Wales. The full implications of this document (popularly known as TAN 8) were not fully appreciated by the local population until National Grid announced their proposals to build the associated infrastructure needed. Unsurprisingly, international energy giants saw £million signs flash before their eyes and piled in with planning applications. Many of us have been horrified by the proposed desecration of our valued landscapes and protested. Powys County Council have considered some of these applications, and have recommended that 5 of them be refused. This automatically triggers a public inquiry.

Public inquires are very expensive. On the one side will be the developers, fattened and bloated on public subsidy (taxpayers and customers money). There is almost no limit to the public's money they have stuffed in their ever open wallets. On the other side is one of the smallest councils in the UK, which can only find the £2.8million the first five applications are going to cost from Council Tax payers. Powys is a comparitively poor part of Britain. Inevitably much of the money will have to be diverted from public services. All this is bad enough (appalling in my opinion), but today's comments from the Welsh Gov't (as reported on the BBC) had made it much worse.

In response to a request from Powys County Council for financial help to carry out its proper role in deciding planning applications the Welsh Gov't says;

"It must be remembered that the decisions to object to the wind farm applications referred to is entirely down to Powys County Council. They were aware of the financial implications when they decided to object to these things"

The position we are in is that councillors serving on my local planning authority are being told by the Welsh Gov't that they should decide applications not on what is right in planning terms, but on the basis of cost - when the developers access the money to pursue their case from public subsidy. And that their multiple applications are driven by Welsh Gov't policy. Its an absolute disgrace. And what will be most disgraceful aspect of all this is that these people will not even understand quite how outrageous this is. Its what happens when one party has been in power for so long, and sees itself beyond the normal democratic process.

6 comments:

JennyKealArt said...

Glyn this is nothing less than state oppression. Forcing Powys residents to pay for defending their environment!

Anonymous said...

Perhaps Powys should ask the Westminster Govt for some money as the energy policy is controlled by them. Ask your friends in power!!

John said...

One Party State Glyn?? I have been blocked from posting the Truth on Conservation of Upland Powys and Montgomeryshire against Pylons,it really speaks volumes.This is more like a One party state! Dont suppose you will post this either! except for the sake of democracy?
Sincerely,
John Jones.

Pete said...

Powys County is one of the poorest counties in Britain, I agree. That is why it is important to allow investment into the County. Millions into this area would boost the economy and provide Technical jobs. Oh yes, I forgot about the massive tourism industry in mid Wales but obviously not big enough to lift Powys out of the 'one of the poorest Counties in Britain' catagory! Get real Glyn!

Anonymous said...

Pete is clearly an avid reader of (and believer in) the wind subsidy industries' sales spiel for the gullible. The permanent jobs are virtually all ABROAD. The remote monitoring and occasional maintenance jobs are tiny in number. It is frankly a Green Lie to suggest that these intermittent industrial wind generators will produce massive local benefits. Even the 'Yeo bribes' would represent a miniscule fraction of the money exported in £billions to foreign 'developers'.

Pete said...

Anonymous is clearly a believer in the mistruths told by the anti brigade (perhaps that's why he/she doesn't want to show their name) who aren't keen on windfarms but have no other suggestions. There are already hundreds in Wales working in this industry. They are not all permantely on site....Sure the turbine manufacturers are abroad, although there are some in the UK. What about the Technicians, Admin staff, accountants, cleaners, PPE suppliers, spare parts suppliers, civil contractors, Ecologists, mechanics....the list goes on, and this is before anymore sites are built. Perhaps you are right, maybe it's better to spend £2.8m stopping investment into Mid Wales...